Core
Hard-to-Fill Recruitment: A Practical Plan for Persistent Vacancies
If a position has remained open despite advertising, the answer may not be another job post. Review the requirements, hiring experience and available talent market to diagnose the bottleneck.
Diagnose the recruitment problem
Check whether there are too few applicants, plenty of unsuitable applicants, slow decision cycles, pay expectations, unusual rosters or inflexible experience requirements. These are different problems and require different responses.
Build an evidence-based shortlist
Define what competence looks like on day one, what can be trained, what must be licensed and how practical skill is tested. Seek feedback on declined offers and compare applicant channels.
Consider national and overseas talent where sensible
If the role is genuinely scarce, investigate adjacent occupations, inter-state candidates and applicable international sources. Review the full cost and likely duration before changing sourcing strategy.
What not to change without evidence
Avoid making every qualification mandatory, using only one advertising channel or assuming a higher salary alone will fix the shortage. Review your actual applicant funnel, reasons for rejection and competing local offers before spending more on recruitment.
Frequently asked questions
Why do our adverts attract unsuitable applicants?
Potential causes include unclear duties, salary mismatch, missing screening requirements and the channel used; a recruitment audit can isolate the issue.
Should we raise salary or broaden the talent pool?
Compare local pay competitiveness and skills requirements before deciding; both may matter.
Do you guarantee hard-to-fill roles will be filled?
No. Success depends on market availability, employment conditions and the specific sourcing capability.