5 Studio Hybrid STR Model: Cash Flow & Break-Even Rate
Worked example: five studios mixing long-term and short-stay rooms. Interest-only and P&I cash, setup costs, sensitivity and break-even nightly rate..
With three long-term and two short-stay studios, Shelby's illustrative model shows A$3,229 a year after interest-only debt and -A$8,905 after principal and interest. The break-even nightly rate at 65% occupancy is about A$170 interest-only or A$207 with principal. Approval and local evidence come first.
Base case
Retrofit total cost A$1,364,750, debt A$887,088 at 7.5%, 25-year term for principal and interest. Long-term: A$375 a week, 95% occupied, 17% variable costs, A$2,000 services per studio and A$10,000 property overhead.
Every mix of five studios
Illustrative inputs, not market evidence: A$180 nightly room rate, 65% of the full calendar booked, three-night average stay, A$80 owner-paid cleaning per turnover, 30% of room revenue for management, platform, maintenance, reserve and consumables, A$3,000 services per short-stay studio, A$1,500 extra property overhead, and A$6,000 setup per short-stay studio plus A$2,000 shared. Pre-tax. Statutory levies and GST are excluded, which is an open item, not an exemption. 5 long-term + 0 short-stay: -A$9,653 a year after interest-only debt, -A$21,787 after principal and interest 4 long-term + 1 short-stay: -A$3,962 a year after interest-only debt, -A$16,096 after principal and interest, extra setup A$8,000, first-year interest-only -A$11,962 3 long-term + 2 short-stay: A$3,229 a year after interest-only debt, -A$8,905 after principal and interest, extra setup A$14,000, first-year interest-only -A$10,771 2 long-term + 3 short-stay: A$10,420 a year after interest-only debt, -A$1,714 after principal and interest, extra setup A$20,000, first-year interest-only -A$9,580 1 long-term + 4 short-stay: A$17,612 a year after interest-only debt, A$5,477 after principal and interest, extra setup A$26,000, first-year interest-only -A$8,388 0 long-term + 5 short-stay: A$24,803 a year after interest-only debt, A$12,668 after principal and interest, extra setup A$32,000, first-year interest-only -A$7,197 (full visitor accommodation, comparison only)
Sensitivity: three long-term plus two short-stay
The 7.5% row is a simple owner-borne revenue sensitivity, not a levy calculator. Lower case: A$140 a night, 45%: -A$20,471 interest-only, -A$32,606 principal and interest A$180 a night, 60%: -A$396 interest-only, -A$12,531 principal and interest Working illustration: A$180 a night, 65%: A$3,229 interest-only, -A$8,905 principal and interest Higher rate: A$200 a night, 65%: A$9,872 interest-only, -A$2,262 principal and interest A$180, 65%, plus 7.5% effective revenue burden: -A$3,176 interest-only, -A$15,311 principal and interest
Break-even nightly rate
Screening thresholds at 65% of the calendar booked, before extra setup, unmodelled capex and statutory taxes. Interest-only: about A$170.28 a night Principal and interest: about A$206.81 a night Evidence must come from approved, similar studios, not whole apartments or hotels
Questions to answer beside these results
Each needs a written answer for the address. Is short-stay use approved for these specific rooms? What resident and guest load is permitted? Will the insurer and lender accept mixed use and does it change the valuation? What does a specialist manager actually charge? Which levy and GST treatment applies? What do comparable approved studios net after discounts and cancellations?
Approval status comes before the numbers
Every mixed scenario on Shelby is shown as hypothetical until the approval status is resolved. A planner's favourable opinion is not a permit, and changing the booking platform never changes the approved use. Approved for the proposed mix Written assessment required Outside the current approval Not assessed
Frequently asked questions
Why does two short-stay studios still lose money after principal?
Principal repayments add about A$12,134 a year. The two-studio mix produces A$3,229 before principal, so it falls to -A$8,905 once principal is included.
What does first-year cash look like?
About A$14,000 of extra setup takes the first-year interest-only result to -A$10,771.
Are A$180 and 65% realistic?
They are illustrative inputs only. Replace them with verified monthly data from comparable approved studios in the same location.