Domera 9 Studio Melbourne Case Study: Yield vs Cash Flow

Compare two cash-flow illustrations for a nine-studio single-title property near Melbourne: partner brochure assumptions versus Shelby's base case after debt.

The partner brochure lists nine furnished studios on one title about 25 minutes from Melbourne's CBD for A$1,810,000. Its 10.34% is gross potential rent divided by price, not an after-cost return. The two pre-tax illustrations show about A$64,238 annually under brochure assumptions and A$24,859 under Shelby's base assumptions after interest-only debt.

Brochure particulars (partner material, unverified)

Current availability and legal status have not been independently established. No exact address or approval pack was provided. Nine furnished studios, nine courtyards, three car spaces, one title Price A$1,810,000; studios 22.39 to 28.53 m2; stated residence area 302.32 m2 Brochure rent A$375 a week per studio plus three couple supplements of A$75

Two cash-flow illustrations

Pre-tax. Base fixed costs include a A$4,000 land tax placeholder. Brochure: A$187,200 rent, 100% occupancy, 20% costs, 6.3% IO, A$64,237.50 a year Shelby base: A$175,500 potential, 95% occupancy, 17% plus A$28,000 costs, 6.3% IO, A$24,859.25 a year

Questions to resolve

The 302.32 m2 area needs reconciling with the endorsed plan and the clause 52.23 measurement method. This does not establish illegality: an actual permit or different area definition may explain it. Title and address, approved as-built plans Permitted use and resident capacity (twelve residents is a condition of the cited exemption pathway, not a universal maximum) Operator and premises evidence Independent rent appraisal, any operating history, insurance and bills Management and rental-guarantee terms, guarantor and exclusions

Hypothetical mixed-use tab (approval: not assessed)

The two long-term cash-flow illustrations, partner brochure and Shelby base, remain the primary analysis. The brochure does not establish short-stay rights, a suitable manager or an exact address. Before modelling any Domera mix, obtain: An intended-use or permit opinion and approved resident and guest load Insurer and lender acceptance of mixed use A specialist short-stay management quote Legal treatment of the Victorian short stay levy for the actual category Local evidence from comparable approved studios Confirmation the rent guarantee or management contract does not exclude short stays Note: a studio with a couple supplement forgoes more long-term income than a single-occupant studio

Frequently asked questions

Is 10.34% the cash return?

No. It is potential rent including couple supplements divided by price. Without supplements it is 9.70%. Cash after costs and debt is much lower.

Sources & References